Thank you for your interest in Untamed Catering! We are excited about turning your next event into “An Event!” complete with sandwiches to match the gravitas of the speech you are planning for the Friday staff meeting, the intensity of the football game you invited all your buddies over for, or the emotions of your wedding day (when the brisket turns out particularly well, we have been known to get a little emotional in the kitchen).

Please note that we need at least 24 hours notice to execute catering orders for less than 30 people, and at least 72 hours notice to execute orders for more than 30 people. If you have less time than that, give us a call and we will try to accommodate you, but we may not be able to.

We add an automatic 10% gratuity for all catering orders. If you would like to tip your servers extra, they will be more than happy to accept it!

Also, we are happy to cater any event that is a reasonable drive away from our shop, but we may need to add an additional catering fee to cover the cost of transportation and onsite prep work if your event calls for it. We will provide you with a quote upfront for those additional costs, and we will never charge more than the costs we incur.

Catering form

Breakfast Catering

Untamed can now cater your breakfast meetings! Choose from a selection of our awesome breakfast sandwiches, plus fresh squeezed orange juice, Brooklyn Roasting coffee or cold brew. Give us a call or email catering@untamedsandwiches.com, and please allow for 48 hours notice for all breakfast catering orders.


Pig Out : (Serves 20)

$184

A selection of all our breakfast sandwiches and freshly brewed Brooklyn roasting coffee.


Have A Meal : (Serves 10)

$107

A selection of all our breakfast sandwiches and freshly brewed Brooklyn roasting coffee.


Have A Bite : (Serves 10)

$70

A selection of all our breakfast spreads on fresh grandaisy rolls and freshly brewed Brooklyn roasting coffee.



Add a gallon of fresh squeezed orange juice for $25
Add yogurt with homemade granola and jam for $6 per person

Lunch/Dinner Catering

The following packages are easy pairings of some of our most popular sandwiches. Sandwiches are cut in half and wrapped as halves so that adventurous eaters can try multiple sandwiches, and so that lighter eaters can take less than a whole sandwich. The packages were designed to make our catering customer’s lives easier with a selection of our most popular sandwiches, but if you would rather pick your own combination of sandwiches, sides, cookies and drinks off of the ala carte menu, please do!

Each catering package comes with your choice of the following sides: Sliced Dill Pickles / Cheddar Jalapeno Grits / Porky Braised Mustard Greens / Pickled Beets with cumin yogurt / Market Greens with goats milk feta and preserved lemon vinaigrette

Grumpy’s Chili Bar : (Serves 10)

$99

Grumpy’s chili bar comes with our grass-fed beef chili and assorted toppings such as pimento cheese, cilantro and jalapenos. Comes with a side of cheddar jalapeno grits

The Little Farm: (Serves 18-23)

$267

A selection of all 6 of our regular sandwiches, skewing more heavily towards the meat-sandwiches that tend to be our most popular.  Frere Jacques, The Butt, The Nettle Neck, General Zapata, Carla Bruni and Sheemakers Bounty.  Comes with 1 family style side dish.

The Medium Farm: (Serves 36-46)

$513

A larger selection of all 6 of our regular sandwiches, skewing more heavily towards the meat-sandwiches that tend to be our most popular. Frere Jacques, The Butt, The Nettle Neck, General Zapata, Carla Bruni and Sheemakers Bounty. Comes with 2 family style side dishes.

The Big Farm: (Serves 54-69)

$761

A very large selection of all 6 of our regular sandwiches, skewing more heavily towards the meat-sandwiches that tend to be our most popular. Frere Jacques, The Butt, The Nettle Neck, General Zapata, Carla Bruni and Sheemakers Bounty. Comes with 3 family style side dishes

The Conscientious Carnivore: (Serves 18-23)

$278

A selection of our 4 meat sandwiches. Frere Jacques, The Butt, The Nettle Neck and General Zapata. Comes with 1 family style side dish.

The Happy Herbivore: (Serves 18-23)

$237

A combination of our 2 vegetarian sandwiches. Carla Bruni and Sheemakers Bounty. Comes with 1 family style side dish.

Add another family style pan of a side dish to any catering order for $72
Add Route 11 Chips for $2.50 per bag
Add drinks for $2.50 each or waters for $2 each
Add house baked cookies for $1.50 each, or Flourless Chocolate Almond Salties (GF) for $2 each